Welcome to Long John Silver’s, one of the only fast-food chains specializing in delicious seafood. The brand pays tribute to the infamous pirate Long John Silver in Robert Louis Stevenson’s classic novel, Treasure Island. Who knew!

Like other fast-food chains Long John Silver’s had to increase their menu prices across the board due to food inflation and increased shipping costs over the past 12 months. But if you’re casting your line for a few good deals, I think we found you some. Here are the up-to-date menu prices on everything from meals to platters below in 2024. 

Family Meals Prices

Menu ItemSize/QuantityPrice
8 Piece Family MealServes 3 - 4$32.99
12 Piece Family MealServes 5 - 6$45.99
16 Piece Family MealServes 7 - 8$52.99
Fish and Shrimp Family Feast$36.99

Platters Menu Prices

Menu ItemSize/QuantityPrice
Fish & Shrimp Platter$12.89
Fish, Chicken & Shrimp Platter$12.89
Fish & Chicken Platter$13.29
Super Sampler Platter$13.19

Meals Menu Prices

Menu ItemSize/QuantityPrice
2 Fish Meal$10.19
3 Chicken Meal$10.39
8 Shrimp Meal$11.29
Fish & Chicken Meal$10.59

Combos Menu Prices

Menu ItemSize/QuantityPrice
2 Fish Combo$9.89
Fish Sandwich Combo$9.39
2 Chicken Combo$9.99
2 Taco Combo$9.99

Grilled Choices Menu Prices

Menu ItemSize/QuantityPrice
Grilled Salmon & Shrimp Platter$13.09
Grilled Shrimp Meal$11.19
Grilled Salmon Meal$11.39
Rice Bowls$10.19
2 Tacos$6.79

Kids Menu Prices

Menu ItemSize/QuantityPrice
Kids Fish Meal$6.09
Kids Chicken Meal$6.09
Kids Popcorn Shrimp Meal$6.19

Seashares Menu Prices

Menu ItemSize/QuantityPrice
15 pc Hand-Battered Shrimp Share$12.00
15 pc Grilled Shrimp Share$12.00
PopCorn Shrimp Sea Share$12.00
6 pc Fish Sea Share$12.00
9 pc Chicken Sea Share$12.00

Sides Menu Prices

Menu ItemSize/QuantityPrice
Green Beans$2.89
Cheese Bites$4.69

Add-A-Piece Menu Prices

Menu ItemSize/QuantityPrice
1 pc Fish$2.99
1 pc Grilled Salmon$3.99
3 pc Shrimp$3.09
3 pc Grilled Shrimp$3.19
Popcorn Shrimp$3.79
Crab Cake$2.79
1 pc Chicken$2.99

Desserts Menu Prices

Menu ItemSize/QuantityPrice
Strawberry Swirl Cheesecake$3.09

Drinks Menu Prices

Menu ItemSize/QuantityPrice
Lipton Sweet Tea$2.99
Lipton Unsweet tea$2.99
Diet Pepsi$2.99
Dr. Pepper$2.99
Mountain Dew$2.99
Sierra Mist$2.99

FAQs about the Long John Silver’s Menu 

What menu items have been discontinued at Long John Silver’s?

Peg Leg

What an incredible name for a menu item, am I right? Long John Silver’s has always been known for its references to pirates and its beloved “Peg Legs” – small chicken drumsticks served with fries atop a bed of crunchy stuff. But, when they discontinued the Peg Legs, many devoted fans boycotted the brand in protest. Sounds like mutiny among the customer base if you ask me. 

Grilled Tilapia

One of their most popular dishes was the Grilled Tilapia, a light and flavorful fish that was a favorite among health-conscious diners. The Grilled Tilapia was a simple yet savory dish. The fish was marinated in a light lemon and herb sauce then grilled to perfection.

You Might Like: Updated Perkins Restaurant & Bakery Menu Prices + Discounts 

The dish was served with a side of vegetables that were cooked to perfection, adding a healthy boost to the meal. The Grilled Tilapia was low in fat, high in protein, and packed a lot of flavors. Unfortunately, Long John Silver’s removed Grilled Tilapia from its menu for unknown reasons. 

Shrimp Scampi

Long John Silver’s Shrimp Scampi was the perfect combination of seafood flavors and comfort food that was sure to please. It was a creamy, buttery, and garlicky combination of shrimp, onions, and mushrooms in a light white wine sauce served over angel hair pasta. The decision to discontinue the dish was a difficult one, but the restaurant made it with the best of intentions.

Here are a few other items that were discontinued at Long John Silver’s:

  • Breaded Catfish
  • Vegetable Medley
  • Breadstick
  • Strawberry Swirl Cheesecake
  • Chicken Strip Sandwich
  • Crab Cake
  • Onion Rings
  • Pecan Pie
  • Iceflow Lemonade
  • Strawberry Iceflow Lemonade

Are there any discounts you can claim at Long John Silver’s? 

Long John Silver’s offers military discounts at participating locations. Get 10% off your order when you present a valid military ID. Plus, receive an extra 20% off your order on Military Mondays at participating locations. With these great discounts, there’s never been a better time to enjoy a delicious meal at Long John Silver’s.

While they do not currently offer senior discounts, Long John Silver’s will also send coupons and special deals or “treasures” to your inbox when you sign up to get special offers with your name, email address, telephone number, and date of birth. Plus, you’ll be the first to hear about special offers so you can take advantage of these deals before anyone else. In my opinion, this is the most consistent way to save money on each visit to the seafood restaurant with limited-time coupons. 

What are the most popular menu items at Long John Silver’s?

Lobster Bites

Indulge in the ultimate seafood experience with Long John Silver’s Lobster Bites. The fan favorite is back for a limited time so get them while supplies last. Enjoy the sweet flavor of succulent Norway Lobster tail, coated in a savory and buttery breading for the perfect flavor pairing in every bite. 

Crispy Fish Sandwich

Enjoy a delicious Crispy Fish Sandwich combo meal from Long John Silver’s with a fried Alaska Pollock sandwich on a roll, topped with tartar sauce and pickles. The meal comes with your choice of side and a refreshing drink. It’s no wonder this classic is one of the most popular items on the menu.

long John silver's bags

Bags of Long John Silver’s seafood.

Hush Puppies

At Long John Silver’s, they bring Hush Puppies to the table like nobody else. Hush Puppies are made with just a few simple ingredients – primarily deep-fried cornmeal and spices – leading to a warm and crispy texture that is surprisingly soft and tasty inside. You can enjoy these tasty and crunchy morsels as a side with your seafood meal at Long John Silver’s. This is a side-item you can’t find at any competitive fast-food joint.

Other popular items at Long John Silver’s include:

  • Grilled Salmon
  • Grilled Shrimp
  • Wild Alaskan Pollock
  • Pacific Cod

Is there a secret menu at Long John Silver’s?

If you’re a seafood lover, you already know the Long John Silver’s brand. The restaurant chain offers classic dishes such as fish & chips and shrimp platters, plus a variety of other seafood dishes. But did you know that there’s a secret menu hacks too? Consider this explanation your treasure map. 

That’s right – while there’s no official ‘secret menu’ at Long John Silver’s there are plenty of ways to get creative with your order and make something unique. With some simple substitutions, you can make interesting flavor combinations that you won’t find on the regular menu. Mixing and matching from the Add-a-Piece menu is the best way to get creative when ordering in my opinion. 

You Might Like: The Complete Cracker Barrel Menu w/ Prices 

For example, if you’re in the mood for something different than the classic fish & chips, why not try a different sauce? You can opt for tartar sauce, cocktail sauce, honey mustard, or even spicy mayo to give your meal a fresh twist. Or, if you’d like to add a side, you can choose from hush puppies, potato wedges, coleslaw and more. The same goes for other dishes, too. If you’re looking to switch things up, you can substitute a different type of fish for the standard cod and opt for something like salmon. 

So next time you visit Long John Silver’s, don’t be afraid to get creative and ask the staff to modify your order. With the right combination of sauces, sides and proteins, you can enjoy a new and exciting meal with each visit. And the best part is that you don’t need an official ‘secret menu’ to make it happen – just ask the staff to help you set sail on a food adventure.

Are there any menu items for specialty diets? 

Long John Silver’s is committed to providing healthy and delicious options for customers. The menu offers a variety of low-fat and low-saturated fat foods, such as grilled salmon and grilled chicken, as well as their signature batter-dipped fish and shrimp. Even their side dishes are a healthy alternative to traditional fast food, when you order the coleslaw or hush puppies. 

Furthermore, they also offer a variety of sides that are healthier than the typical fast-food side. These include coleslaw, macaroni and cheese, and French fries. All of these items tend to be lower in fat and calories than those you may find at other fast-food restaurants. This makes it easier to make healthier choices when it comes to your side dishes.

Who is the target audience of this Long John Silver’s menu?

Long John Silver’s is a unique fast-food seafood chain that’s been around for over 50 years and continues to serve up delicious seafood to its loyal mates. The restaurant has a core customer base that consists of mostly middle-aged to elderly individuals. This is why Long John Silver’s relies more on repeat customers than a mass quantity of one-time customers. 

Long John Silver’s knows its target audience and caters to them by utilizing wacky commercials that attract attention and make customers want to try something new. They also understand the power of word of mouth and rely heavily on customer feedback. 

Overall, Long John Silver’s has found success by understanding its target audience, creating commercials that attract the right customers, and utilizing customer feedback to stay on top of the ever-changing demands of its customers.

In September 2011, Long John Silver’s became 80% franchise-owned. This change has helped the chain to expand its presence and better serve its customers. The company currently has more than 1,300 locations in the United States, Canada, and Mexico.