At Cold Stone Creamery you can choose from one of 18 signature creations or build a custom concoction of your own by ordering from an extensive list of ice cream flavors, syrups, fruits, and other toppings. In addition to dessert, you always get a show at Cold Stone Creamery where employees double as entertainers tossing and juggling the ice creams before mashing together the toppings and sauces on a cold granite stone. 

But before you go to Cold Stone Creamer, don’t forget to check out the updated menu prices for 2024. I also share the secret menu items you need to try on your next visit and how to claim a BOGO coupon right now. 

Ice Cream Signature Creations

Ready Now Cakes & Novelties

Football Party

Shakes Menu 

Family Packs

DIY Cupcakes Kit

Create Your Own Creation

Create Your Own Ice Cream Cakes & Novelties

For Your Freezer

FAQs about the Cold Stone Creamery Menu 

What menu items have been discontinued at Cold Stone Creamery?   

Once in a while, ice cream shops decide to shake things up by rearranging the menu or eliminating specials. Sometimes they remove underperforming menu items and unexpectedly eliminate popular items. This is usually fine unless an item you loved is taken away forever.  

All that being said, let’s take a trip down memory lane and look at the discontinued items at Cold Stone Creamery. 

• At the Cocoa Banana Cabana – Banana Ice cream, Fudge, Whipped Topping, Banana, Yellow Cake
• Banana Split Decision – Banana Ice cream, Fudge, Roasted Almond, Strawberry
• Monkey Bites – Banana Ice cream, Pecan, Coconut, Crunch Bar, Banana
• Candy Land – Cake Batter Ice cream, Snickers, M&M’s, KitKat
• Cherry Cake Double Take – Cake Batter Ice Cream, Honey, Roasted Almond, Black Cherry, Yellow Cake
• Cherry Loves Cheesecake – Cheesecake Ice Cream, Fudge, Chocolate Chip, Black Cherry
• Black Forrest Dream – Chocolate Ice Cream, Fudge, Cherry Pie Filling, Brownie
• Rocky Road Trip – Chocolate Ice Cream, Roasted Almond, Marshmallow
• Breathless Boston Cream Pie – French Vanilla Ice Cream, Fudge Whipped Topping, Yellow Cake
• Coconut Cream Pie – French Vanilla Ice Cream, Whipped Topping, Coconut, Graham Cracker Pie Crust

You Might Like: Updated Dairy Queen Menu Prices on All Your Favorites 

• Pecans and Cream Passion – French Vanilla Ice Cream, Caramel, Pecan, Graham Cracker Pie Crust
• Health Nut – Skinny Vanilla Ice Cream, Peanut Butter, Roasted Almond, Banana
• Sinless Island – Skinny Vanilla Ice Cream, Coconut, Pineapple
• Very Berry Good – Skinny Vanilla Ice Cream, Strawberry, Raspberry, Blueberry
• Apple Pie a la Cold Stone – Sweet Cream, Caramel, Apple Pie Filling, Graham Cracker Pie Crust, Cinnamon
• Caramel Turtle Temptation – Sweet Cream, Caramel, Fudge, Pecan
• Strawberry Shortcake Serenade – Sweet Cream, Whipped Topping, Strawberry, Yellow Cake
• Nights in White Chocolate – White Chocolate Ice Cream, Caramel, Whipped Topping, White Chocolate Chip
• Paradise Found – White Chocolate, Coconut, Pineapple, Banana

You can order your ice cream birthday cake from Cold Stone Creamery.

Are there any menu items for specialty diets?  

One word of warning if you have allergies to common ingredients like eggs, tree nuts, peanuts, soy, milk or gluten you’ll want to carefully read the food allergens and sensitivity chart provided by the company here.

For example, here are a few of the menu items that contains a specific wheat / gluten allergen: Banana Bread Batter Ice Cream, Boo Batter Ice Cream, Cake Batter Ice Cream, Chocolate Cake Batter Ice Cream, Classic Cookie Dough Ice Cream, Fudge Brownie Batter Ice Cream. Note: Refer to the companies full food allergens and sensitivity chart before visiting a store for details.

If you’re a vegan and have a sweet tooth at the same time, Cold Stone offers one plant-based product, which is Chocolate Silk Almond Milk Frozen Dessert. Additionally, all Cold Stone Sorbet flavors are lactose-free.

Here are some keto-approved menu items with their amount of net carbs at Cold Stone Creamery:

• Chocolate Chips Mix-in with 2g of net carbs
• Raspberries with 4g of net carbs
• Rainbow Sprinkles with 6g of net carbs
• Chocolate Shavings with 7g of net carbs
• Smooth Craving 70cal Hot Cocoa Mix with 8g of net carbs

Are there any discounts you can claim at Cold Stone Creamery? 

Everyone can join the loyalty program called My Cold Stone Club Rewards Member. When you sign up for the program, you’ll get a coupon for a buy one, get one free creation that’s valid on the next visit. 

You’ll also start earning 1 reward point for every $1 you spent at Cold Stone Creamery. Once you reach 50 points (or $50 in spend), you earn a coupon for $5 off. When you think about it, signing up for My Cold Stone Club Rewards saves you 10% off every single purchase.

Of course the benefits don’t end there. They’ll also give you a buy one, get one creation offer on your birthday and other surprise discount offers throughout the year. 

Military members and active and retired veterans are eligible for a discount at select Cold Stone franchise locations worldwide. Be sure to ask about this deal if you’ve served. 

How to redeem a birthday coupon at Cold Stone Creamery?

In order to have a birthday coupon, you must sign up for My Cold Stone Club® Rewards. Then the birthday BOGO, which is the coupon, will be loaded 7 days ahead of your birthday in your account. This coupon is redeemable in any Cold Stone Creamery store and is valid for two weeks, a week on, and a week after your birthday.

How to redeem a Cold Stone Creamery coupon?

Pick the coupon you are looking for and make sure it can be applied to your order. Also, some coupons or vouchers can be redeemed at select Cold Stone Creamery outlets.

What are the most popular menu items at Cold Stone Creamery?

It’s easy to become overwhelmed when viewing all of Cold Stone Creamery’s menu items. Worry not. Here are some of the most popular menu items you can add to your short list. 

1. Cake Batter Ice Cream 
2. Chocolate
3. French Vanilla
4. Cotton Candy
5. Coffee Ice Cream
6. Strawberry
7. Founder’s Favorite
8. Sweet Cream
9. Cake Batter ‘n Shake
10. Classic Cookie Dough

Still, at Cold Stone Creamery, there are endless possibilities to try your best ice cream list and a wide array of fun creations.

Is there a secret menu at Cold Stone Creamery?

Yes, there are secret menus at Cold Stone Creamery. These menu items can be made if you tell this secret code to the ice cream server and a new flavor surprise awaits you. Here are some secret menu items to level up your ice cream experience. 

• Peanut butter and jelly – Peanut butter and jelly sandwiches may appeal to sweet sandwich lovers. The basic three-ingredient sandwich is sweet enough for indulgences like ice cream. Cold Stone Creamery’s rendition of peanut butter & jelly ice cream features a scoop each of peanut butter and watermelon sorbet.  
• Cherry Cobbler –  Cold Stone sells cherry cobbler-flavored ice cream but not cobblers.  Here’s how you can get a cherry cobbler: Get French vanilla with yellow cake pieces and cherry pie filling from Cold Stone Creamery. Adding graham crackers to the treat adds substance. The resulting cherry cobbler-like ice cream is excellent for warmer weather.

• Coconut Cream Pie – Coconut lovers, rejoice! Cold Stone Creamery now offers ice cream in the flavor of coconut cream pie! French vanilla ice cream, a very adaptable base, combine graham cracker pie crust, whipped cream, and plenty of crushed coconuts to produce this flavor.
• Arroz con Leche – Rice pudding, or Arroz con Leche in Spanish, is a typical Mexican delicacy made with sweetened condensed milk, vanilla essence, and cinnamon. It’s the perfect base for ice cream. To make a delectable treat, Arroz con Leche ice cream is formed by mixing two Cold Stone Creamery flavors: Cotton candy ice cream with cinnamon ice cream.  
• Ants on a Log – Ants aren’t in flavor. This flavor mimics kids’ favorite Ants on a Log. Peanut butter and raisins on celery make this snack. French vanilla ice cream, chocolate-covered sea salt pretzel, raisins, and peanut butter are blended to make a slightly salted version of the childhood delight. The crunchy, chewy, salty, and creamy flavors and textures are unique.

You Might Like: 251+ Timeless Ice Cream Shop Slogans and Quotes for Ad Campaigns 

• Chocolate Gooey Butter Cake – Chocolate complements numerous desserts. Chocolate ice cream is also great. Chocolate makes a butter cake even more delicious. Ask your server to mix cake batter, ice cream, fudge, cake, and brownie crumbs. Most chocolate enthusiasts will appreciate this cool, sweet, and exquisite dessert. 
• Dulce de Leche – This soft, sweet Latin American caramel is perfect for the sweet tooth! Order French vanilla ice cream with cinnamon and lots of caramel. 
• Boston Cream Pie – This top-secret flavor from Cold Stone Creamery mixes French vanilla ice cream, yellow cake pieces, whipped topping, and fudge to create a dessert that recalls Boston cream pie but with a richer custard base.
• Key Lime Pie – Blending lemon sorbet, cake batter ice cream, and graham cracker pie crust yields a hidden menu item that tastes almost like Key lime pie. Cheers to a creamy, lemony, and tangy treat! 
• Pineapple Upside-down Cake – Pineapple ice cream fans can indulge in the hidden menu item pineapple upside-down cake ice cream at Cold Stone Creamery. Maraschino cherries are an optional bonus for those with a desire for decadence.

Chocolate dipped strawberry ice cream featured on Twitter.

Are there any menu items for special diets or healthy choices?

Many Cold Stone Creamery sorbet products are vegan. There is also a plant-based frozen dessert menu item, Silk® Chocolate Almondmilk Frozen Dessert – this ice cream alternative is just like the real deal. Cold Stone Creamery caters to everyone who craves ice cream or wants to cool off. These menu item choices are a variety of sweet treats that leads to healthier options: sorbet, frozen yogurt, sinless sans fat sweet cream, skinny vanilla ice cream, creations for kids, and smoothies.

Who is the target audience of this restaurant’s menu?

The target audience of Cold Stone Creamery is families with children, teenagers, adults, and elders. Basically, all their products if for people of all ages because almost everyone loves ice cream. The wide array of creations in Cold Stone Creamery provides the ultimate experience for any age to cater to their preferences. They can even create their combinations. 

What is the Founder’s Favorite® item at Cold Stone Creamery?

Made with classic sweet cream ice cream coated in fudge and caramel and topped with delicious pecans and brownies – this menu item is a classic, and its name suggests the favorite creation of the Cold Stone Creamery founders. You can’t help but fall in love with how the flavors taste so well together.

Does Cold Stone Creamery cater events?

Of course! Cold Stone Creamery will always be a treat everyone needs to cool off during parties. Cold Stone Creamery is ready to sweeten your event, whether you’re hosting a birthday party, engagement, retirement, or wedding. Just contact the nearest store in your local area to finalize your booking date. You can also request custom-made cakes for any occasion. 

Cold Stone Creamery is owned and operated by Kahala Brands. The company got started operating in Scottsdale, Arizona, and have expanded to more than 900 stores globally.