In an era where dining trends come and go, Peter Luger remains steadfast, offering a traditional steakhouse experience that’s authentic and memorable since 1887.
While many flock to Peter Luger for its unparalleled steaks and classic ambiance, there’s another aspect that often piques curiosity – the menu prices. In this article, I share the updated prices, new menu items, and the dress code if you plan to visit their location in Brooklyn or Long Island.
Page Contents
Appetizers
| Menu Item | Size / Quantity | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Mixed Green Salad | $10.95 | |
| Iceberg Wedge Salad | $16.95 | |
| Caesar Salad with Grated Pecorino Romano | $13.95 | |
| Shrimp Cocktail | 4 pcs. | Market Price |
| Shrimp Cocktail | 6 pcs. | Market Price |
| Luger’s Sizzling Bacon | 1 pc. | $4.95 |
| Sliced tomatoes & onions with Luger’s sauce | $14.95 | |
| Sliced tomatoes with Luger’s sauce | $14.95 |
Main Courses (Dinner)
| Menu Item | Size / Quantity | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Single Steak | $51.95 | |
| Rib Steak | $54.95 | |
| Steak (Good for 2) | $103.90 | |
| Steak (Good for 3) | $155.85 | |
| Steak (Good for 4) | $207.80 | |
| Lambchop | 2 pcs. | $52.95 |
| Grilled Atlantic Salmon | $28.95 | |
| Filet of Sole (Lamb & Fish) | $29.95 |
Lunch Specials
| Menu Item | Size / Quantity | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Pot Roast (Every Monday Only) | $16.95 | |
| Roast Prime Rib of Beef (USDA Prime) (Tuesday - Friday Only) | $32.50 | |
| Filet of Sole (Lamb & Fish) (Tuesday & Friday Only) | $23.95 | |
| Chicken (Home Style) (Every Wednesday) | $19.95 |
Daily Lunch Specials
| Menu Item | Size / Quantity | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Luger-Burger with Bacon | $20.95 | |
| Chopped Steak (USDA Prime) | $18.95 | |
| Luger-Burger with Cheese | $16.45 | |
| Luger-Burger with Fries | $18.90 | |
| Luger-Burger | $14.95 | |
| Grilled Salmon with Potato & Vegetable of the Day | $22.95 | |
| Lambchops | 2 pcs. | $26.95 |
Salad Dressing, Toppings, & Extras
| Menu Item | Size / Quantity | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Blue Cheese Dressing | $0.75 | |
| Vinaigrette Dressing | $0.75 | |
| Garlic French Dressing | $0.75 | |
| Russian Dressing | $0.75 | |
| Add Chopped Bacon | $4.95 | |
| Add Crumbled Blue Cheese | $5.95 |
Vegetables & Sides
| Menu Item | Size / Quantity | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Onion Rings | $11.95 | |
| Creamed Spinach | $10.95 | |
| Broccoli | $9.95 | |
| Baked Potato with Sour Cream | $6.95 | |
| German Fried Potatoes | $12.95 | |
| French Fries (Good for 1) | $6.95 | |
| French Fries (Good for 2) | $11.95 |
Dessert
| Menu Item | Size / Quantity | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Luger’s Special “Holy Cow” Hot Fudge Sundae | $12.95 | |
| Fresh Fruit | $11.95 | |
| Sorbet | $11.95 | |
| Pecan Pie | $11.95 | |
| Fruit Tarts | $11.95 | |
| Cheese Cake | $11.95 | |
| Ice Cream | $11.95 | |
| Key Lime Pie | $11.95 | |
| Chocolate Mousse | $11.95 | |
| Apple Strudel | $11.95 |
Coffee & Tea
| Menu Item | Size / Quantity | Price |
|---|---|---|
| German Coffee | $12.95 | |
| Irish Coffee | $12.95 | |
| Coffee, Decaf, or Tea (Lunch) | $2.50 | |
| Coffee, Decaf, or Tea (Dinner) | $3.50 |
What is the dress code at Peter Luger?
Believe it or not, there’s no official dress code at Peter Luger. This is a traditional steakhouse with casual dress requirements. Bottom line, as long as you are wearing a shirt, shoes, not wearing anything with objectionable messages and are clean, you will not have a problem being served at Peter Luger.
A gourmet burger at Peter Luger.
Does Peter Luger Accept Cash?
Yes, Peter Luger does accept cash payment at the Brooklyn and Great Neck locations. Peter Luger Steak House does not accept credit cards. They do, however, accept the Peter Luger Card, US checks with proper ID, US debit cards, and cash.
There is a slight workaround to this, however. For online orders only, credit card payments are permitted. You can have steak, sauces, and gift cards shipped to your work or home address. They’ll even ship food internationally.
Daily Luncheon Specials.
What’s the Corkage Fee?
According to New York Magazine, Peter Luger does not offer this service to guests. Fortunately, Peter Luger offers an extensive collection of fine wines to choose from onsite.
Does Peter Luger have a Michelin Star?
Yes, Peter Luger Steak House in Brooklyn lost its Michelin star.
Why did this happen? The loss of the Michelin star for Peter Luger might be attributed to changing perceptions of what constitutes a fine-dining establishment in the modern era. The steakhouse, which has been described as a “cash-only joint with overpriced plates and rude waiters,” may no longer align with contemporary standards of fine dining.
Additionally, Peter Luger received a zero-star review from The New York Times three years prior, indicating that there might have been signs of declining recognition for some time. Despite the loss of the Michelin star, Peter Luger remains confident in its offerings and identity. The general manager, David Berson, emphasized the restaurant’s commitment to serving the best steak and showed gratitude to their loyal customers. Berson also made a remark contrasting their signature steak with the “latest kale salad,” highlighting the restaurant’s traditional approach to dining.
Explore the menu at Peter Luger.
New Menu Items?
Peter Luger rarely adds new items to its menu. But in 2023, they’ve introduced a tantalizing new dish that’s got everyone talking: a steak sandwich!
David Berson, the fourth-generation operator and general manager of the restaurant, revealed the idea of a steak sandwich had been simmering in the back of their minds for years. The challenge? Crafting a sandwich that felt like it had always been a part of the timeless legendary menu. After countless trials and taste tests, they’ve perfected the recipe and are ready to release it into the public.
A traditional steakhouse experience.
The sandwich boasts a generous 8-ounce portion of USDA Prime New York strip steak, cooked to perfection. It’s then topped with caramelized onions and a zesty horseradish spread. The sandwich is served on a toasted roll that’s reminiscent of the onion bread from Luger’s complimentary bread basket.
You Might Like: Morton’s Steakhouse Menu Prices + Power Hour
This $38 steak sandwich is an exclusive treat, available only through word-of-mouth during lunch hours from Monday to Thursday at their Williamsburg and Long Island branches. If you’re dining at Peter Luger for lunch, it’s worth asking about no matter what location you’re at.
In addition to this delectable sandwich, Peter Luger introduced sautéed mushrooms, crab cakes, and a ribeye for two. This is another dish designed to seamlessly blend with the classic menu. So, the next time you’re at Peter Luger, lean in and whisper your order for that steak sandwich or ribeye meal for two.
